Recently I have been traveling across the eastern half of the United States, meeting with various theatrical minds, students, their teachers and practictioners in residence at some of the more respected Theatrical training programs. One of the more interesting and beneficial conversations, up to this point, was with a man who is not only Faculty in the Carnegie-Melon Drama Dept, but also has a lengthy resume of professional experience.
Primarily it was a discussion regarding the work of the Director, but as the Director sits atop the body as it’s head, the conversation encompassed nearly every aspect of the Theatre. We were discussing a certain play and my ideas regarding its significance, the themes at work etc and my vision for production. I produced a sketch of the set for the play and proceeded to explain the various elements, why the ground plan was laid out as it was, this character’s space in this place and another character’s space in that, what the spacial relationship defined between the two etc. When that portion of the discussion was over, and the gentleman had genuinely and politely praised the work, I felt obligated to tell him something regarding the development of the sketch/vision.
I only understood the design, after I had sketched it. There was nothing conscious in its development. I read the play, as I always do in an initial reading, just to get a sense of it, purely for enjoyment really. Then I read it again, this time with an open mind to whatever the playwright’s work evoked within me, emotionally, visually, spiritually or otherwise. There is no set order to these things, sometimes several of them come together in one sitting, other times it takes a reading with each one specifically in mind for anything at all to be sort of conjured up. In the instance of this play, and as I told this gentleman, upon reading the play a second time a clear physical world for the play existed in my mind. I quickly sketched it before it could slip away, no doubt to never be brought up again with the same visceral and organic vitality as the original. Days later I looked back at the sketch. This time I could see, clearly, the meaning of every character’s space. Why I had placed it where I did. What the intangible significance was of specific elements, the imagery I was attempting to create for the audience with suggestive elements rather than literal ones. This is the way it usually was for me and it was something I longed to understand.
With a smile and a nod the gentleman said to me, I am not surprised by this at all. Do you know the difference between a Notion and an Idea? I responded by saying, well I would think I do, but tell me… …a Notion is just what you had when you made this sketch. Something unfounded, a “wouldn’t it be cool if”…when you came back to it later and could support it, could back it up as not just being cool, but being meaningful and effective, a truth…then it became an Idea. Not all of our Notions become Ideas. Some of them are really nothing more than, wouldn’t it be cool if… …because, while it might be cool…if it can’t be supported, proven as doing service to the telling of the story, then it would also be ineffective or even detrimental to the piece.
This conversation has been rattling around in my brain for the better part of two months…and it has impacted a great deal of the small projects or developmental work I’ve been a part of since then. I find myself even more liberated than I was before. Open and available to every Notion that presents itself. Not bothering to judge them in the instant I have them, as being good or bad, right or wrong. Simply allowing myself to “have the Notion”, perhaps make a note of it. Then come back to it later, test it against the text or other elements of the work to determine if it was merely a Notion…or if it could in fact be fully developed into an Idea.
Notions keep us interested, searching, longing…hungry. Developing them into Ideas, that keeps us sharp, teaches us to be appropriately critical and makes your work as an Artist effective to your Audience. There will no doubt be further posts exploring this concept of Idea vs. Notion. As it has caused me to have a rather large notion regarding its meaning on a grander scale. I am excited to find out if it’s merely that…a notion…or in fact…an Idea.